Jill Allen
Partner
Buffalo
Practice Areas
Insurance Defense
Personal Injury
about me
credentials & achievements
professional Focus
affiliations
significant matters
media
insights
About Me
Jill Allen is a litigation partner with a dynamic practice representing both plaintiffs and defendants in civil matters involving insurance defense and personal injury. Drawing on experience from both sides of the docket, she brings a balanced, strategic perspective to every case – anticipating opposing arguments, identifying opportunities early, and positioning clients for the best possible outcomes.
Jill approaches the practice of law with a focus on practicality and results. She understands that for some clients, litigation can be deeply personal and overwhelming and for others, it is a matter of managing risk and controlling costs. She tailors her approach, accordingly, providing clear guidance, proactive communication, and efficient case handling. Throughout her career, Jill has successfully handled cases from initial investigation through trial and has achieved favorable outcomes through motion practice, negotiation, and alternative dispute resolution. She is particularly valued for her ability to evaluate cases early, develop practical litigation strategies, and adapt quickly as matters evolve. She has been an Upstate New York Super Lawyers, Rising Stars, from 2023-2025, and Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America, 2026.
Outside the office, Jill enjoys spending time with her husband, Scott, and son, JD. She is also a certified Baptiste Yoga Instructor and Lagree Instructor. She values maintaining a strong work-life balance and brings that same grounded, thoughtful perspective to her work with clients and colleagues.
Credentials & Achievements
Education:
University at Buffalo School of Law, J.D.
Trinity College, B.A.
Admissions:
New York
United States District Court for the Western District of New York
Achievements:
Upstate New York Super Lawyers, Rising Stars, 2023-2026
Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America, 2026, 2027
Professional Focus
Capabilities:
- Representation of individuals in personal injury matters, including serious and catastrophic injury claims.
- Motor vehicle accident litigation, including automobile, trucking, and commercial vehicle cases.
- Premises liability claims involving slip-and-fall incidents, negligent security, and property-related injuries.
- Construction site accident and Labor Law litigation.
- Defense of bodily injury and personal injury claims on behalf of insurance carriers and insured clients.
- Insurance cover analysis and dispute resolution.
- Early case assessment and exposure evaluation for insurers and corporate clients.
- Development of cost-effective litigation and resolution strategies aligned with client objectives.
- Drafting and arguing dispositive motions, including summary judgment motions.
- Management of all phases of discovery, including depositions, expert retention, and document review.
- Mediation, arbitration, and alternative dispute resolution advocacy.
- Trial preparation and courtroom representation in state and federal courts.
- Counseling clients on risk management and claims handling best practices.
- Coordination with claims professionals, adjusters, and in-house counsel throughout the litigation process.
Industries Served:
- Insurance
Affiliations
- New York State Bar Association
- New York State Academy of Trial Lawyers
Significant Matters
- Represented insurance carriers and insured entities in high-exposure personal injury and construction accident cases, managing all phases of litigation through resolution
- Defended complex New York Labor Law matters involving multiple parties, successfully navigating risk transfer and minimizing client exposure
- Secured significant victories on summary judgment and successfully defended outcomes on appeal, including before the Appellate Division, Fourth Department
- Took over personal injury cases from prior counsel and achieved substantially higher settlements than previously recommended, through strategize case development, targeted discovery, and effective negotiation
- Advised clients on indemnity provisions to strengthen defenses and improve litigation outcomes
- Handed cases involving serious bodily injury claims arising from construction accidents, premises liability, and motor vehicle accidents
Media
Jacob Honan Featured in 2026 Upstate New York Super Lawyers Cover Story
31 Rupp Pfalzgraf Attorneys Named 2026 Super Lawyers & Rising Stars
How Industry-Specific Challenges Shape Succession Planning
New York Enacts Personnel Records Access Law: What Employers Need to Know
28 Rupp Pfalzgraf Attorneys Recognized by Best Lawyers® in 2027 in America
Summer Associate Spotlights
What to Consider Before You Assemble Your Succession Planning Team
New York May Soon Require Large Employers to Report Annually on AI’s Impact on Jobs
Jamie Batt Named to the 2026 Power 200 Women List
The Cost of Delay: Why Liquor License Strategy Matters in New York
Insights
Jacob Honan Featured in 2026 Upstate New York Super Lawyers Cover Story
Jacob Honan Featured in 2026 Upstate New York Super Lawyers Cover Story October 5, 2026 Home / Rupp Pfalzgraf attorney Jacob Honan is featured in the cover story of the 2026 Upstate New York Super Lawyers magazine. The story, "Next Gen," brings together four Rising...
31 Rupp Pfalzgraf Attorneys Named 2026 Super Lawyers & Rising Stars
31 Rupp Pfalzgraf Attorneys Named 2026 Super Lawyers & Rising Stars September 29, 2026 Home / We are excited to share that 31 Rupp Pfalzgraf attorneys have earned places on the 2026 Upstate New York Super Lawyers and Rising Stars lists! This achievement highlights...
How Industry-Specific Challenges Shape Succession Planning
How Industry-Specific Challenges Shape Succession Planning September 22, 2026 Home / By Jamie Batt Succession planning is never one-size-fits-all, and the industry a business operates in often shapes the plan more than owners realize. The right approach for a...
New York Enacts Personnel Records Access Law: What Employers Need to Know
New York Enacts Personnel Records Access Law: What Employers Need to Know September 15, 2026 Home / By Matt Miller For the first time, New York employers will need a formal process for employees to access their personnel files. On September 9, 2026, Governor Hochul...
28 Rupp Pfalzgraf Attorneys Recognized by Best Lawyers® in 2027 in America
28 Rupp Pfalzgraf Attorneys Recognized by Best Lawyers® in 2027 in America August 31, 2026 Home / Rupp Pfalzgraf is proud to have 28 attorneys recognized in the 2027 editions of The Best Lawyers in America® and the Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch® in America! Recognition...
Summer Associate Spotlights
Summer Associate Spotlights August 4, 2026 Home / This summer, we welcomed six summer associates to our Buffalo office: Molly Little, Easton Warner, Bill Minarchi, Dominic Fragale, Michael Calandra, and Elizabeth Fox. Throughout the summer, they’ve gained hands-on...
What to Consider Before You Assemble Your Succession Planning Team
What to Consider Before You Assemble Your Succession Planning Team August 4, 2026 Home / By Jamie Batt Many business owners know they should be thinking about succession but aren’t sure where to start. Assembling a team of trusted advisors is an important step in the...
New York May Soon Require Large Employers to Report Annually on AI’s Impact on Jobs
New York May Soon Require Large Employers to Report Annually on AI’s Impact on Jobs August 4, 2026 Home / By Matt Miller New York’s Legislature has passed a bill that would require large employers and publicly traded companies to report every year to the state...
Jamie Batt Named to the 2026 Power 200 Women List
Jamie Batt Named to the 2026 Power 200 Women List August 4, 2026 Home / We are proud to share that Rupp Pfalzgraf Partner Jamie Batt has been named to the 2026 Power 200 Women list by Buffalo Business First! The Power 200 Women is an annual list that highlights 200...
The Cost of Delay: Why Liquor License Strategy Matters in New York
The Cost of Delay: Why Liquor License Strategy Matters in New York August 4, 2026 Home / By Rachel Wright Many business owners choose to file their own liquor license application in an effort to reduce upfront costs. What is often overlooked, however, is the financial...









